In ShortRoughly a third of women have fantasized about this. You are one of a third, not one of a kind. Bringing it up yourself is harder than it should be, and that is societal pressure sitting on both of you, not something wrong with either of you.
The most-cited survey on sexual fantasy in the United States found that roughly a third of women have fantasized about their partner being with someone else, or about being with someone else while he watched.
One in three.
Nobody ever quotes that one. The number people quote is the men's, and it gets repeated so often that this whole thing reads like something that happens to wives instead of something wives want.

“I care that you stop apologizing for having one.”
I want it. I have wanted it for a long time. And I am writing this for the woman who wants it and has not said so.
You were raised into a sentence
A good wife does not want this.
Nobody sat you down and said it. You absorbed it, the way I did, from church and television and your mother and a thousand small comments about other women. By the time you were old enough to want anything, that sentence was already in you.
It is why I never asked, and not in the way you would think. It was not that I wanted it and was too afraid to say so. I never thought about it at all. My husband was my husband and I did not fantasize about other men. The only place any of it lived was in the talk we had in our own bedroom and in what we shared anonymously online, and both of those were something we did together.
So there was nothing in me to bring up. That is how completely a sentence like that works. It does not just stop you saying the thing. It stops you thinking it.
I needed someone to tell me the door was real. My husband asked me, and that is the only reason I found out who I was.
He was raised into a sentence too
A real man does not share.
He did not pick that one either. It was handed to him younger than you got yours, and it is enforced harder, with a word built specifically to punish him for it.
This matters for you, because it is the thing standing between you and the conversation you want to have.

